all of you seem to not take notice of champions as tanks. i'd like to add them to the list.
sure, guardians are just THE tank class and cappy/warden can be fine. but champs can tank very well, too.
They have 60% physmits and 65% tactmits. tactmits can get to 70% passively when wearing 2 setbonus of osgiliath instances, putting them on the same tactical level like guards. they have up to 10% (2% per point) melee damagereduction whenever their fervor is up (which is the case very often) and can have 10% damagereduction for all types with 100% uptime when they use 4-set-bonus of featured gear. and they can block. and they have a bigger morale-pool than guards (+20% morale by traitbonus). and they still do decent dps while tanking, which normally solves all aggro problems.
just the panic-skills are quite bad (only one okayish one with 1min cd and 15sec uptime, rest nearly useless).
still, i prefer champtanks over beorns and chanking is really funny :P
biggest reason why nearly no one uses champs as tanks is their awesome (aoe)dps
Diskutierer, Fragenbeantworter, Twinker, Händler, Handwerker und Anführer der 'Gemeinschaft der freien Völker' auf Belegaer