I thought I would see what the other good cappys use.
Innocence I think is a must have. Then I use empathy and idealism, not very commonly used by others, but gives me actually a pretty good amount of fate and extra armor. Last 2 are compassion and loyalty.
All my other toons have zeal, even my warden, but not on my cappy, I don't think having an extra 800 health is worth losing those mits and fate (except I do have loyalty but hey armor and vitality in the same virtue... Yeah I'll take it)
Anyway I already got the deeds up, I'm sure they're not the perfect combo but at least I got them to 15 or 16 finally.