Wine Wine Wine. Dry Dry Dry. What will it be today ?...
Don't push it. Don't push it or I'll give you a war you won't believe.
~John J. Rambo
I'm alright with the lorebook being gone as usually I used the wiki instead. I do agree though that not having the character info to be shared outside the game is kind of a downer. We also can't note anymore the accomplishments our characters or friends did recently. Those are the two features that I miss and could hope they bring back. Otherwise, the new site/forums are pretty nice.
Worst thing / decision ever made by Turbine was to deactivate these services.
Anyway, the features of the old website are going nowhere. Leading up to the forum revamp and since, Sapience has made it pretty clear between the lines (planned or unwittingly) that management wished for a bare-minimum forum service. One can expect that, aside from tweaks and bugfixes here and there, noone is ever going to touch the workings of this forum again until LotrO marches into the twilight.
What kind of company cuts those features? A smart one. Q.E.D.
I somehow suspect you were going for an answer more along the lines of a dying company, but then I'd counter with: A Company recently announced a major addon pack for their flagship product, redecorated their headquarters lobby with the theme of their flagship product, redesigned and re-deployed the website for their flagship product, is doing a major class overhaul of their flagship product, created a player council to help drive the design of their flagship product, and took the option to extend the IP rights to make their flagship product. What kind of company makes such a large investment in their flagship product?
I might be a little too late for the topic since the discussion already took a proportion that makes me unable to read the "whole" content of it. So if someone pointed this out already on the previous pages, sorry.
I really think that the my.lotro service was really the major loss. Lorebook wasn't that usefull, since not only lotro wiki is much more used by the players, also there are THOUSANDS of websites with lore information, items, quests, walkthroughs, cosmetics tips etc.
I can't really complain about the forums and the website, since I've noticed a huge difference on loading the pages. The main issue I have with the new forums is that the color is really boring. Makes me want to sleep. I rather browse a forum with light backgrounds with colors such as white or light blue with traditional black letters. Some might think light colors are too strong, but they make it much more easy to read in my opinion. However, that's up to the designers and I bet they had their reasons to keep a darker forum.
Now onto my.lotro. My lotro was useful in MANY ways. Specially for kinship leaders. Being able to connect with guild launch effectively and monitor your kinship stats outside the game would make the life of the kinships easier. I don't really see how my.lotro was a "heavy" service to the servers. Honestly, I come from a SA-MP roleplaying community (you might argue that we're talking about smaller communities, however most of sa-mp RP servers have a single server, while turbine probably has much more space for processing and storing data), and it is common on that RPing communities to have an User Control Panel connected to the server (IRC channel aswell to monitor item log and death logs), to manage your character spawing points, check stats, check your kick/warning/ban history, monitor your items AND most importantly, for leaders of factions that are sponsored by the server (aka Official factions), a panel to see your roster, modifiy it, promote, demote, kick etc. And I'm talking about 10.000 of unique accounts in a server that supports 500 players and usually have around 300-400 online.
What I'm trying to say is, Turbine could solve the problems by creating an User Control Panel. I'm not an expert in the subject, I'm actually a complete outsider of web design and stuff, but I can't see how showing the data that is being processed 24/7 in game can be that heavy to processing data. The data is there, right now, as we write here, the data is safe and avaible for acess in game at anytime. All that Turbine needs is to show that data out of game. Correct me if I'm wrong, but it is pretty much an /inspect command on the browser. Having /inspect doesn't make the server slow.
I've read a few threads in the past with complaints about my.lotro regarding "privacy issues". People claiming that they didn't want their "data" to be avaible for everyone (which is non-sense since in game data is not yours, it is Turbine property, if you forgot you've agreed to their EULA, and it doesn't displays any real life information, unless you want to), and that can be solved with making the data only avaible for registered players and by extending the "anonymous" function.
Well, I'm not sure if I'm in the right topic or if I should post this in the suggestion section. The point is, my.lotro can be brought back with simple UCP features.
I'm pleased that the (new) site loades faster then the (terrible loading-times) of the old one,
BUT I'm not amused about the cut off the Lorebook AND the Character Informations !
I'm sad that Turbine makes such an decision, without taking an ear to it's own Community!
(did they want that, or not? - did they need that? - are those sites used often?)
I really NEED for example the chance to look, who is an alt/twink of somebody else,
or to take if an old friend still playing (activity log) or gone away for ever,
and some of the other nice features that Turbine is cutting away.
Please bring them back, in wich case ever (maybe with lesser load of your servers,
but i'm be interested in the CONTENT of that informations, that they brought with!)
This should petition should be broken up into it's 3 components.
1. The lore book got removed with no replacement
--- NOT signed. Easily found elsewhere. Requires constant resources on Turbines part.
2. Links to display character information out of game do not work anymore.
--- NOT signed. This requires developing and maintaining the web interface--evidently Turbine doesn't want/have the resources to do that--I won't argue with them. A web interface takes time to build, and must constantly address issues with changes to the game and more importantly updates to browsers. It's a resource hog for Turbine. Let other people do it by implementing the next item: #3
3. No API or other way to keep up with game items and their properties seems available to players
--- /SIGNED /SIGNED /SIGNED This. Providing, behind the scenes, a method for OTHER sites to do #2 as well as locate player alts and other things that require access to a current data base is the huge loss that only Turbine can fix. If they would put the one time (mostly) effort into fixing that, and offering the API to the public, it should require little maintenance in the future (it's not a gui--just an automatic database dump and access hook to the dumped data). Maybe a tweak here and there with updates, but nothing like maintaining a graphic interface that works on all systems and breaks on every new browser that comes out. PLEASE offer this again. If you do, I would wager within 2 months there would 2 or 3 sites that offer every functionality the old my.lotro forums had, and then some. This is all that's needed to fix 99% of the loss functionality by letting fan sites take up the banner.
I can see that maintaining and managing the lorebook could be to much effort for Turbine and that a fast and reliable forum has number 1 priority. On the other hand, I assume it would be very well in the interest for a company to allow their player base some form of immersion into the game without starting up the client and fully login into the game itself. A working API to provide access to game data would be a good compromise. This should not be too much work. All the information is already generated and available in the game and its data bases.
I was using the character web interface and LotroHerald a lot, although many items didn't show up anymore.
I do not know if LUA-plugins could partially fill in and dump character data into a file, for example. This file could then be read by another 'out-of-game' program which has a nice user interface. Do plugins have access to the items a character has currently equipped? The inventory plugins I have running have only access to the bags, vaults, and the shared storage.
So, I am still hoping for some kind of API.
I work on a product in which I just ripped out a fair-sized feature. Why? Because it was causing serious problems for some customers (driving up our customer service costs), and it wasn't used by a very high percentage. Fixing it would have cost far more than it was worth, so the decision was made to remove it. I fully expect to hear some complaints for that decision, but we cannot let the needs of a few drive what we invest in - not unless those few are willing to pony up rather large amounts of cash. We're not a government, which can attempt to do it all and just tax people more to pay for it. We have to make careful decisions about what gets development, and what doesn't.
I miss the character info sections. It was a great Kinship management tool and just helpful all around. I'm a professional developer and, if the database is updated anyway, I'd be happy to take a look at volunteering my skills to keep it going. Obviously the character info has to be stored and updated somewhere.
"We want"?? no, maybe YOU want.
I, for one, prefer the new, fast, forum to the old buggy, slow one. Nor do I need the lorebook--wiki is much better. Never used the char. stuff anyway.
I like the new format.
i think if those features like the lorebook and others worked as they were intended to then they would have been used more often. The lorebook had missing information that i wanted to find out and/or bad links, so i often times went to the lotro wiki first, then the lorebook if the wiki wasn't enough. I would have gladly went to the lorebook for everything if it worked without problems.
Maybe we should contact the plugins scripters to ask about the possibility of such a plugin.
There are plugins that goes beyond macro reading. I think we should bring this discussion to lotrointerface.com.
For those wondering about a Lua solution to this, there are a couple of issues. First and foremost is that the GetEquipment() method has a bug which crashes the client when a plugin which calls GetEquipment is loaded and unloaded multiple times such as when switching between characters (it usually takes 8-10 load/unloads but can crash in as little as 2 depending on various factors). In addition, even if the client crash gets fixed, there is very limited information available to Lua for items, basically just the name and icon information. There are no stats available so it would be nearly meaningless to display the available information in a third party application outside the game.
Basically, at this time, Lua can not offer a suitable means of replacing the lost functionality.
Srange enough, lotroarmory seems to be up-to-date.
I never own a Toyota and I will never own one as long the dealer in my town sale his cars in a backyard.
That means, the actally "Revamp" looks very cheep like a beginners fun site.
This game has no Item Database, no Lorebook anymore, no statistics and all the other features which other games such Aion, SWTOR and many more has.
This game has nothing and now this cheep revamp with cuted vBulletin to vBulletin Lite or Trial.
Someone who may interested on Lotro, visit this site just once, and the next click is back to Google.
Just an example that you don't need to cut functions to have a fast site.
i agree with op 100%
We really need some way to view our character data outside of the game, whether it be viewing the equipment, stats, crafting levels, deed completion history, or simply the total money we have on any of our character. Doing this in-game simply takes a lot of time and as the op pointed out its really hard to keep track of these attribute on multiple toons at once..
I for one have multiple toons on multiple servers, which means I now need to completely exit the game and restart it to get to my alts on other worlds which is just ridiculous.
Being a software developer myself I can understand the difficulty that the team faces with keeping up with broken forms (the old ones ie) and the character data gathering service but I would say making an API and giving it to other developers is a good alternative (this was there before as well when other websites simply get the data out of my.lotro and data.lotro) so they can make there own webapps and save us the impossible hassle.
I hope they take it into consideration
This form's session has expired. You need to reload the page.Reload