Can only support the idea. Imladris had pretty decent fights in the past. Like already mentioned the 1vs1 dont follow any common rule, mostly both parts use all they have, but if people for example see a defiler is not heal spamming most freeps dont heal themselves too and vice versa. It's also no problem to ask for no cd fights i'd say, since many creeps also have freeps and you can just talk to them. Good thing for our server is, that in all the time i played, i only once saw some form of ganking 1vs1 (i understand it as mostly wargs/burgs killing players that just sparred and are at low morale). Zerging 1vs1 has happened a few times, but i guess pretty low compared to other servers from what i've seen. (So pls make sure you dont bring this kind of people here).
Quite a lot freeps, also high ranked ones, are just waiting for action to grow again before they get their vip back, so make sure in case you pick Imladris to bring creeps aswell (many of the creeps left here didnt play before HD) but maybe if total numbers increase, our creep veterans that didnt transfer yet will be playing more too