PVP bug between reavers and captains.

[Armitas]

FYI
Take a look at this bug posted by Mormirel. According to the post the reaver skill blood of fire turns into a hot on the captain when revealing mark is used. It may also cause a captains damage to be reflected back though.

No the intended effect of the mark is not what I mean, there is a bug.
Intended is that something like 15% of the damage dealt to the target is reflected as +morale to the cappy/the cappy's allies.

What happens is that either the intended effect applies, but also the full 45 fire damage from blood of fire are applied as + morale healing, not as fire damage. Or -somewhat seldomly- the cappy gets no healing at all but the 45 fire damage + 15% of whatever damage he dealt to the reaver reflected back at him. That is not wai, but a bug.

See this combat log, names have been changed (notice the recurring 45 healing from blood of fire and the cases where light and beleriand damage get reflected back at the captain):

[09/27 02:23:32 PM] Reaver reflected 45 points restored to the Morale of Captain.
[09/27 02:23:32 PM] Reaver scored a hit with Sundering Blow on Captain for 123 Fire damage to Morale.
[09/27 02:23:32 PM] Captain scored a critical hit with Cutting Attack on Reaver for 97 Beleriand damage to Morale.
[09/27 02:23:33 PM] Captain scored a critical hit with Improved Grave Wound on Reaver for 97 Beleriand damage to Morale.
[09/27 02:23:33 PM] Captain scored a hit with Improved Grave Wound on Reaver for 312 Beleriand damage to Morale.
[09/27 02:23:33 PM] Reaver reflected 47 points restored to the Morale of Captain.
[09/27 02:23:33 PM] Reaver reflected 45 points restored to the Morale of Captain.
[09/27 02:23:33 PM] Reaver scored a hit with Laceration on Captain for 39 Fire damage to Morale.
[09/27 02:23:34 PM] Captain scored a hit with Cutting Attack on Reaver for 44 Beleriand damage to Morale.
[09/27 02:23:34 PM] Captain scored a hit with Valiant Strike on Reaver for 394 Beleriand damage to Morale.
[09/27 02:23:34 PM] Reaver reflected 59 points restored to the Morale of Captain.
[09/27 02:23:34 PM] Reaver reflected 45 points restored to the Morale of Captain.
[09/27 02:23:35 PM] Captain scored a hit with Improved Grave Wound on Reaver for 44 Beleriand damage to Morale.
[09/27 02:23:35 PM] Reaver scored a critical hit with Laceration on Captain for 72 Fire damage to Morale.
[09/27 02:23:35 PM] Captain missed trying to use a melee attack on Reaver.
[09/27 02:23:36 PM] Reaver scored a hit with Default Melee Attack on Captain for 52 Fire damage to Morale.
[09/27 02:23:36 PM] Captain scored a hit with Cutting Attack on Reaver for 44 Beleriand damage to Morale.
[09/27 02:23:36 PM] Reaver scored a partially evaded hit with Default Melee Attack on Captain for 27 Fire damage to Morale.
[09/27 02:23:37 PM] Captain scored a hit with Improved Grave Wound on Reaver for 44 Beleriand damage to Morale.
[09/27 02:23:37 PM] Reaver scored a devastating hit with Sudden Strikes on Captain for 228 Fire damage to Morale.
[09/27 02:23:37 PM] Captain missed trying to use Improved Blade of Elendil on Reaver.
[09/27 02:23:37 PM] Reaver scored a hit with Laceration on Captain for 46 Fire damage to Morale.
[09/27 02:23:37 PM] Reaver scored a hit with Sudden Strikes on Captain for 86 Fire damage to Morale.
[09/27 02:23:38 PM] Captain missed trying to use a melee attack on Reaver.
[09/27 02:23:38 PM] Captain scored a hit with Cutting Attack on Reaver for 44 Beleriand damage to Morale.
[09/27 02:23:39 PM] Captain scored a hit with Improved Grave Wound on Reaver for 44 Beleriand damage to Morale.
[09/27 02:23:39 PM] Reaver scored a hit with Laceration on Captain for 42 Fire damage to Morale.
[09/27 02:23:39 PM] Captain scored a hit with Improved Sure Strike on Reaver for 362 Beleriand damage to Morale.
[09/27 02:23:39 PM] Reaver reflected 54 points restored to the Morale of Captain.
[09/27 02:23:39 PM] Reaver reflected 45 points restored to the Morale of Captain.
[09/27 02:23:39 PM] Reaver scored a partially parried hit with Ravage on Captain for 93 Fire damage to Morale.
[09/27 02:23:40 PM] Reaver scored a hit with Ravage on Captain for 107 Fire damage to Morale.
[09/27 02:23:40 PM] Captain scored a hit with Cutting Attack on Reaver for 44 Beleriand damage to Morale.
[09/27 02:23:41 PM] Reaver scored a hit with Ravage on Captain for 107 Fire damage to Morale.
[09/27 02:23:41 PM] Captain scored a hit with Improved Grave Wound on Reaver for 44 Beleriand damage to Morale.
[09/27 02:23:41 PM] Captain scored a hit with a melee attack on Reaver for 329 Beleriand damage to Morale.
[09/27 02:23:41 PM] Reaver reflected 49 points restored to the Morale of Captain.
[09/27 02:23:41 PM] Reaver reflected 45 points restored to the Morale of Captain.
[09/27 02:23:41 PM] Reaver scored a hit with Default Melee Attack on Captain for 52 Fire damage to Morale.
[09/27 02:23:41 PM] Reaver scored a hit with Default Melee Attack on Captain for 37 Fire damage to Morale.
[09/27 02:23:42 PM] Reaver scored a hit with Sudden Strikes on Captain for 114 Fire damage to Morale.
[09/27 02:23:42 PM] Captain scored a critical hit with Battle-shout on Reaver for 437 Light damage to Morale.
[09/27 02:23:42 PM] Reaver reflected 45 points restored to the Morale of Captain.
[09/27 02:23:42 PM] Reaver reflected 66 points restored to the Morale of Captain.
[09/27 02:23:42 PM] Reaver scored a hit with Sudden Strikes on Captain for 86 Fire damage to Morale.
[09/27 02:23:42 PM] Captain scored a critical hit with Cutting Attack on Reaver for 97 Beleriand damage to Morale.
[09/27 02:23:43 PM] Captain scored a critical hit with Improved Grave Wound on Reaver for 97 Beleriand damage to Morale.
[09/27 02:23:43 PM] Captain scored a hit with a melee attack on Reaver for 452 Beleriand damage to Morale.
[09/27 02:23:43 PM] Reaver reflected 68 points restored to the Morale of Captain.
[09/27 02:23:43 PM] Reaver reflected 45 points restored to the Morale of Captain.
[09/27 02:23:43 PM] Reaver scored a hit with Default Melee Attack on Captain for 52 Fire damage to Morale.
[09/27 02:23:43 PM] Reaver scored a hit with Default Melee Attack on Captain for 37 Fire damage to Morale.
[09/27 02:23:43 PM] Captain missed trying to use Devastating Blow on Reaver.
[09/27 02:23:44 PM] Reaver scored a hit with Sudden Strikes on Captain for 114 Fire damage to Morale.
[09/27 02:23:44 PM] Reaver scored a hit with Sudden Strikes on Captain for 86 Fire damage to Morale.
[09/27 02:23:44 PM] Captain scored a critical hit with Cutting Attack on Reaver for 97 Beleriand damage to Morale.
[09/27 02:23:45 PM] Captain scored a hit with Improved Grave Wound on Reaver for 44 Beleriand damage to Morale.
[09/27 02:23:45 PM] Captain scored a hit with a melee attack on Reaver for 313 Beleriand damage to Morale.
[09/27 02:23:45 PM] Reaver reflected 47 points restored to the Morale of Captain.
[09/27 02:23:45 PM] Reaver reflected 45 points restored to the Morale of Captain.
[09/27 02:23:45 PM] Reaver scored a hit with Default Melee Attack on Captain for 52 Fire damage to Morale.
[09/27 02:23:45 PM] Reaver scored a hit with Default Melee Attack on Captain for 37 Fire damage to Morale.
[09/27 02:23:46 PM] Captain scored a hit with Improved Blade of Elendil on Reaver for 579 Beleriand damage to Morale.
[09/27 02:23:46 PM] Reaver reflected 87 points restored to the Morale of Captain.
[09/27 02:23:46 PM] Reaver reflected 45 points restored to the Morale of Captain.
[09/27 02:23:46 PM] Reaver scored a hit with Sundering Blow on Captain for 123 Fire damage to Morale.
[09/27 02:23:46 PM] Captain scored a critical hit with Cutting Attack on Reaver for 97 Beleriand damage to Morale.
[09/27 02:23:47 PM] Captain scored a hit with Improved Grave Wound on Reaver for 44 Beleriand damage to Morale.
[09/27 02:23:48 PM] Captain missed trying to use a melee attack on Reaver.
[09/27 02:23:48 PM] Reaver scored a hit with Default Melee Attack on Captain for 52 Fire damage to Morale.
[09/27 02:23:48 PM] Reaver scored a hit with Default Melee Attack on Captain for 37 Fire damage to Morale.
[09/27 02:23:48 PM] Captain scored a critical hit with Cutting Attack on Reaver for 97 Beleriand damage to Morale.
[09/27 02:23:48 PM] Captain missed trying to use Pressing Attack on Reaver.
[09/27 02:23:49 PM] Reaver scored a hit with Jagged Cut on Captain for 132 Fire damage to Morale.
[09/27 02:23:49 PM] Captain scored a hit with Improved Grave Wound on Reaver for 44 Beleriand damage to Morale.
[09/27 02:23:49 PM] Captain missed trying to use Pressing Attack on Reaver.
[09/27 02:23:50 PM] Reaver scored a hit with Default Melee Attack on Captain for 52 Fire damage to Morale.
[09/27 02:23:50 PM] Reaver scored a critical hit with Default Melee Attack on Captain for 55 Fire damage to Morale.
[09/27 02:23:50 PM] Captain scored a hit with Cutting Attack on Reaver for 44 Beleriand damage to Morale.
[09/27 02:23:50 PM] Captain scored a hit with a melee attack on Reaver for 358 Beleriand damage to Morale.
[09/27 02:23:50 PM] Reaver reflected 54 points restored to the Morale of Captain.
[09/27 02:23:50 PM] Reaver reflected 45 points restored to the Morale of Captain.
[09/27 02:23:50 PM] Reaver scored a hit with Ravage on Captain for 143 Fire damage to Morale.
[09/27 02:23:51 PM] Captain scored a hit with Improved Grave Wound on Reaver for 44 Beleriand damage to Morale.
[09/27 02:23:51 PM] Reaver scored a hit with Ravage on Captain for 107 Fire damage to Morale.
[09/27 02:23:51 PM] Captain scored a hit with Improved Sure Strike on Reaver for 386 Beleriand damage to Morale.
[09/27 02:23:51 PM] Reaver reflected 58 points restored to the Morale of Captain.
[09/27 02:23:51 PM] Reaver reflected 45 points restored to the Morale of Captain.
[09/27 02:23:52 PM] Reaver scored a hit with Ravage on Captain for 107 Fire damage to Morale.
[09/27 02:23:53 PM] Reaver scored a hit with Default Melee Attack on Captain for 52 Fire damage to Morale.
[09/27 02:23:53 PM] Captain scored a hit with Improved Grave Wound on Reaver for 44 Beleriand damage to Morale.
[09/27 02:23:53 PM] Reaver scored a hit with Default Melee Attack on Captain for 37 Fire damage to Morale.
[09/27 02:23:54 PM] Reaver scored a hit with Default Melee Attack on Captain for 52 Fire damage to Morale.
[09/27 02:23:54 PM] Reaver scored a hit with Default Melee Attack on Captain for 37 Fire damage to Morale.
[09/27 02:23:55 PM] Captain scored a hit with Improved Grave Wound on Reaver for 44 Beleriand damage to Morale.
[09/27 02:23:56 PM] Captain scored a hit with a melee attack on Reaver for 402 Beleriand damage to Morale.
[09/27 02:23:56 PM] Reaver reflected 60 points restored to the Morale of Captain.
[09/27 02:23:56 PM] Reaver reflected 45 points restored to the Morale of Captain.
[09/27 02:23:56 PM] Captain scored a critical hit with Cutting Attack on Reaver for 97 Beleriand damage to Morale.
[09/27 02:23:57 PM] Captain scored a partially evaded hit with Improved Cutting Attack on Reaver for 234 Beleriand damage to Morale.
[09/27 02:23:57 PM] Reaver reflected 35 Beleriand damage to the Morale of Captain.
[09/27 02:23:57 PM] Reaver reflected 45 Fire damage to the Morale of Captain.
[09/27 02:23:57 PM] Captain scored a hit with Improved Grave Wound on Reaver for 44 Beleriand damage to Morale.
[09/27 02:23:57 PM] Reaver scored a hit with Default Melee Attack on Captain for 52 Fire damage to Morale.
[09/27 02:23:57 PM] Reaver scored a partially parried hit with Default Melee Attack on Captain for 24 Fire damage to Morale.
[09/27 02:23:57 PM] Reaver scored a hit with Lacerate on Captain for 143 Fire damage to Morale.
[09/27 02:23:58 PM] Captain scored a hit with a melee attack on Reaver for 332 Beleriand damage to Morale.
[09/27 02:23:58 PM] Reaver reflected 50 points restored to the Morale of Captain.
[09/27 02:23:58 PM] Reaver reflected 45 points restored to the Morale of Captain.
[09/27 02:23:58 PM] Captain scored a critical hit with Cutting Attack on Reaver for 97 Beleriand damage to Morale.
[09/27 02:23:59 PM] Captain scored a hit with Improved Grave Wound on Reaver for 44 Beleriand damage to Morale.
[09/27 02:23:59 PM] Captain scored a hit with Battle-shout on Reaver for 185 Light damage to Morale.
[09/27 02:23:59 PM] Reaver reflected 45 Fire damage to the Morale of Captain.
[09/27 02:23:59 PM] Reaver reflected 28 Light damage to the Morale of Captain.
[09/27 02:23:59 PM] Reaver scored a critical hit with Laceration on Captain for 69 Fire damage to Morale.
[09/27 02:24:00 PM] Captain scored a critical hit with Cutting Attack on Reaver for 97 Beleriand damage to Morale.
[09/27 02:24:01 PM] Captain incapacitated you.
[09/27 02:24:01 PM] Captain scored a critical hit with Devastating Blow on Reaver for 1,879 Beleriand damage to Morale.
[09/27 02:24:01 PM] Reaver reflected 282 points restored to the Morale of Captain.
[09/27 02:24:01 PM] Reaver reflected 45 points restored to the Morale of Captain.

[GeorgeBaggy]

FYI
Take a look at this bug posted by Mormirel. According to the post the reaver skill blood of fire turns into a hot on the captain when revealing mark is used. It may also cause a captains damage to be reflected back though.

Has this been tested against a Defiler as well?

[Armitas]

I haven't heard of any test with a defiler.

[Omen_Kaizer]

I was at a 1v1 circle today (fought a reaver and a defiler), and I noticed I had two reveal mark icons on one of them. I guess it was the reaver--don't rightly remember. However, I distinctly remember only seeing 1 green number above my head each time I hit him.

I didn't really look at the magnitude of it, whether it was one green number for 30% or just 15%.

I'll get back to you as I'll be going back out today.

[gungus_coyote]

Am I looking at this correctly? Are the CA and Grave Wound DoTs reflecting back to the Cappy as 45-66 morale heals instead of damage?

I fought a couple of reavers tonight with revealing mark on them, my CA and Grave Wound DoTs all reflected back as damage. If this is a bug, it doesn't appear to apply consistantly. Is it possible that it only happens when certain factors are applied in a certain order, like only on Tuesdays and it has to be raining?