There seem to be a bug / error in one of the two following guild cloak recipes:

Forceful Cloak of the Deep and Skillful Cloak of the Deep. They both have the same stats:

Armor: 1111
Agility: 217
Vitality: 186
Fate: 62
Physical Mastery Rating: 563
Finess Rating: 425

If I compare with other guild gear at L95, I believe the error is that the Skillful Cloak of the Deep should have:

Armor: 1111
Agility: 217
Vitality: 186
Physical Mastery Rating: 563
Critical Rating: 563
Finess Rating: 425

If someone at Turbine reads this, please fix the Skillful Cloak.

And people/players, don't comment something stupid like "lol", or that "make a bug report". This is my report, and if Turbine don't read it, it's their shame.